| Date | Lecture | Speaker |
|---|---|---|
| 15.09.2026 | Taboo Topics We Can No Longer Avoid: Negligence, Tampering, and FraudIn general, the public have a high degree of trust in science. But has this trust been earned; is science trustworthy? In this talk, I argue that for an enterprise tasked with discovering truth, science has a surprising lack of formal and effective quality assurance mechanisms. In general, there are stronger quality assurance mechanisms to ensure that food is safe to eat than to ensure that scientific articles contain truths rather than falsehoods. This talk outlines, from a firmly pro-science perspective, some of the recent threats to the trustworthiness of science and efforts to quantify and improve it. This will include discussion of both bottom-up grassroots efforts by so-called "science sleuths” as well as top-down institutional adoption of quality control mechanisms. Such changes require that we, as scientists, confront uncomfortable topics. Ensuring the integrity and credibility of the scientific record likely requires that we abandon the assumption that intentional fraud is exceptionally rare, and that we confront the threats posed by honest error, negligence, and recklessness. |
Ian Hussey, University of Bern |
Research Integrity and the Quest for Treatments for Alzheimer’s Disease (online)Why is a meaningful treatment for Alzheimer’s disease so elusive? The biological complexity of the disease is undeniable, but effective treatments are emerging for other exceedingly complicated neurological diseases. An uncomfortable possibility is that lapses in research integrity may have misdirected a meaningful portion of Alzheimer’s disease research over the last several decades. This talk will explore major cases of research misconduct surrounding research into neurodegeneration and discuss forensic methods, regulatory processes and the fallout from misconduct, closing with a call for structural changes to our scientific institutions to make them more resilient to abuse. Publishers must take a more active role in detecting research misconduct and correcting problematic data in the literature. Institutions should strengthen misconduct investigations by making them timely, independent and transparent. And individual scientists should commit to not being silent bystanders, but actively promote integrity and rigor in research. |
Matthew Schrag, Vanderbilt University | |
| 29.09.2026 | Protecting Research Integrity -- A Practitioner’s ViewFor two decades, natural sciences have been plagued by a failure of replication crisis. In the humanities, plagiarism cases paint an equally dire picture. A vast amount of research, often dating back many decades, calls for a renewed critical review. While the advent of AI technologies facilitates such reviews, one is afraid that it will also bring new waves of research . Alongside scientists' associations, journals, and academies, universities investigate alleged breaches of standards of research conduct. The presentation will explain the regulation and procedure that control investigations carried out for the University of Zurich. Problems, failures, and successes of university-based investigations will be discussed. Alternative mechanisms and measures of prevention will be looked at. The speaker, who has contributed to the University’s efforts and will continue to do so, expresses his personal views. |
Wolfgang Ernst, University of Zurich |
When every hypothesis is published: AI, the exploitation of Open Science Assets, and false discoveries (online)Open science has given us a shared public good, in the form of publications and public datasets, free to access and reuse by anyone. But AI can now generate, test and write up hypotheses against those assets faster than our community can evaluate them. This talk looks at what happens to open repositories when they become inputs to industrial-scale hypothesis generation, and whether this is likely to become a systemic problem. We will also provide case studies of outputs that can be generated in under an hour, and examples of the impact on the literature (including the de facto banning of some open science resources altogether). It also asks what data stewards, funders and publishers can realistically do about it. |
Matt Spick, University of Surrey | |
| 13.10.2026 | Philosophy of Scientific MalpracticeMuch of the discussion about scientific misconduct is shaped by high-profile cases of fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism (FFP) committed by a few individual researchers. Likewise, policies, regulations, and research integrity training often focus on the responsibility of individual scientists to avoid such misconduct and on where and how to report it when they encounter it in others. In this talk, I argue that we should pay greater attention to the vast grey zone of ignorance, negligence, sloppiness, wishful thinking, and overconfidence that lies between responsible research and outright fraud. Rather than concentrating solely on detecting deliberate misconduct, we should also train collaborators and mentors to recognize and respond to warning signs when results seem unusual, inconsistent, or simply too good to be true. Strengthening this capacity for critical caution may do more to safeguard research integrity than an exclusive focus on rare cases of intentional fraud. |
Hanne Andersen, University of Kopenhagen |
No Research Integrity without True Scientific SpiritAccording to the scientist and philosopher Charles S. Peirce, for science not to be corrupted and to progress towards its constitutive aim of truth or knowledge, it is both necessary and (to a large extent) sufficient that it is conducted with a "true scientific spirit". Prima facie, this view sounds quite implausible, for two opposite reasons: i) the "true scientific spirit" requirement, as Peirce understands it, is very demanding and looks strongly counterintuitive because, as I will show, it seems to exclude as unscientific many research activities that are usually categorised as properly scientific; ii) it does not seem that satisfying this requirement would guarantee the integrity of science. I will argue that Peirce's view is defensible when combined with Pierre Bourdieu's central claims about how the scientific field should be regulated to enable genuine scientific progress. |
Benoit Gaultier, University of Zurich | |
| 27.10.2026 | Phantastic Images and Where to Find Them (and How to Deal with Them) (online)Systematic reviews of preclinical research are used to synthesize evidence, evaluate study quality, and guide future research. Beyond estimating treatment effects, they provide a powerful lens through which to assess the validity, reproducibility, and integrity of published research. In this presentation, I discuss how systematic reviews can also uncover research integrity concerns, including image duplication and potential paper-mill activity, with substantial implications for the trustworthiness of an evidence base. I will outline emerging AI-assisted approaches for detecting problematic publications and discuss how researchers can contribute to detecting and mitigating these problems. |
Kim Wever, Radboud Medical Center, Nijmegen |
Journals as Curators Rather than PublishersThe journal eLife is published by a nonprofit organization that is funded by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, the Wellcome Trust, the Max Planck Society, and the Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation. Founded in 2011 and publishing its first peer-reviewed articles in 2012, the mission of the journal is to reform the scientific publishing process, improve research culture, and develop open technologies to facilitate constructive scientific peer review and publishing. From the beginning, eLife implemented a consultative peer review process in which editors required peer reviewers to come to common recommendations. These recommendations represented a consensus on feedback and (as applicable) requested revisions as well as the decision to reject, require revisions, or accept a manuscript for publication in the journal. In 2023, eLife shifted to an author-driven publishing model that is increasingly used in several academic publishing communities and is called publish-review-curate (PRC). Under this model, peer reviewers do not make the decision of whether to publish a manuscript. Rather, authors publish their manuscripts (e.g. as preprints on established preprint servers) and journals provide reviewing and curation services. The task of eLife editors became to answer peer review requests (submissions) with a decision regarding whether the journal had the interest and capacity to peer review a preprinted manuscript, and then to conduct the consultative peer review process as applicable. The outcome of the peer review process under this model is not an accept/revise/reject decision, but a brief assessment using standardized language alongside feedback to the authors. The authors then decide whether and how to revise their manuscript, as a result of which the assessment is re-evaluated and may change. The authors also decide whether and at which step to request that eLife register their peer-reviewed manuscript as a version of record alongside the public peer reviews and assessment. The uptake of the PRC model as a full process by an established journal has generated many interesting discussions. I will provide my perspective as a researcher, one of the first authors of an eLife article (published in the first 2012 issue), and an editor at eLife. |
Meredith Schuman, University of Zurich | |
| 10.11.2026 | Healing Science from the Inside Out: Meta-Science as a Vital Path to Public TrustWhat sustains the public’s confidence in science, and what can scientists do to strengthen it? We tend to look outside for the answer: to public misunderstanding, partisan media, or political ideology. This talk makes a less comfortable case. Trust is relational: it cannot be demanded, least of all by a community whose spirit is to question everything. It has to be earned, but trust can be eroded by routine practices that we excuse as the lesser evil. Underpowered studies and the selective publication of significant results rarely feel dishonest, yet they fill the literature with findings that fail to accumulate into knowledge. Since such practices are common, rewarded, and largely invisible, they are a systemic problem rather than an isolated one. Rather than asking the public for faith, we should earn trust through self-scrutiny. That is the work of meta-science, which turns the tools of research back on research itself. In addition, meta-science is also an attitude: a reflexivity that asks scientists to examine not only their methods but their relationship with the public they serve. The talk argues that this is where public trust has to begin. |
Ye Sun, University of Georgia & University of Zurich |
Studying the Research System: Metaresearch, Incentives, and Research Assessment ReformWhen fabricated data or manipulated images come to light, we usually hear that "it’s the incentives". The way research is rewarded is blamed for pushing researchers toward cutting corners. This talk takes that premise seriously and asks what metaresearch can tell us about it. What does the system actually reward? Promotion criteria at universities overwhelmingly count publications and grants, while practices that make research trustworthy, such as data sharing or study registration, are barely mentioned. Funders send similar signals in what they ask researchers to report after a grant is completed. Researchers in turn end up believing that only papers count. The result is a self-reinforcing circle that no single researcher, university or funder can easily leave. How can evidence from metaresearch help break this circle? I will present examples from our own work at the Center for Reproducible Science and Research Synthesis. Finally, I will explain how current research assessment reforms and other policy interventions came about, and why they need to be evaluated too. |
Rachel Heyard, University of Zurich | |
| 24.11.2026 | Equating Research Integrity with Good Scientific Practice – a Journey with Moving Goal-posts.Abstract coming soon… |
Edwin Constable, University of Basel |
Understanding the Spectrum of Questionable Research Practices Helps to Promote Research IntegrityQuestionable research practices (QRPs) - also termed detrimental or unacceptable practices - are actions that are not at the level of research misconduct, but threaten the actual and perceived integrity of researchers and their work. Current research integrity guidelines acknowledge how difficult it can be to separate QRPs from research misconduct. I will examine a range of examples to demonstrate that QRPs exist on a continuum - stretching from honest mistakes to more serious behaviours. By viewing QRPs through this lens, we can better address their underlying causes and effectively build integrity and transparency into responsible research practice. |
Leonhard Held, University of Zurich | |
| 08.12.2026 | How Supervision Can Foster Good Research PracticeAbstract coming soon… |
Tamarinde Haven, Tilburg University |
Podium Discussion: Fighting Scientific MisconductAbstract coming soon… |
Tamarinde Haven, Tilburg University Elisabeth Stark, University of Zurich Rachel Heyard, University of Zurich Leonhard Held, University of Zurich |
Ringvorlesung
Programme
Location: University of Zurich, KOL-F-118 (main building)
Time: 18:15 – 20:00